How It Works - Becoming a Consignor

Thank you for considering becoming a consignor at A Second Look!

In a Nutshell: 

Gather your best 30 items or less. Be sure to look them over closely for flaws; items must be in new or like new condition and be in current fashion. (see the "condition of items" below for assistance) No appt needed. Just stop on in. 50/50 split. Consignment period is 60 days. See the Consignment Agreement below for more details. 


What is Accepted:

  • Women’s and Teen’s Casual Clothing, Purses, Shoes, Accessories & Men’s/Young Men’s CASUAL Clothing and Shoes – IN SEASON

Not Accepted:

  • Women’s - suits, dress pants, dress shoes, fashion scarves, worn undergarments, worn swimsuits, bridal gowns, mother of the bride/groom dresses, bridesmaid dresses, prom dresses
  • Men’s - suits, suit jackets, dress shirts, dress pants, dress shoes, ties

Condition of Items:

  • All items must be freshly laundered, free of pet hair and odors, and in “like new” condition – if items need to be lint rolled/cleaned there will be $1 per item charged to your account and a $5 fee per load if deemed necessary.
  • Must be within 2-3 years old and in current fashion
  • Please review the “Condition of Items” and “Brands that are NOT Accepted” section to assist in selecting items to consign. Items that are dropped off and do not meet these standards will automatically be donated and you will not be notified.

Other Information:

  • Consignment period is 60 calendar days. It is the consignor’s responsibility to track the 60 days. Your account is accessible online at under “Consignor Login”. If you are unsure of how to log in, please ask.
  • ONLY ITEMS ORIGINALLY PRICED $49.99 OR HIGHER will be available to pick up if they do not sell. You will have 5 calendar days to pick your items up after the expiration date. We can provide you with a list of the expired items, but you will need to pull your own items off the sales floor and bring them to the counter so they can be removed from the system. On day 66, items that are not picked up, along with items priced under $49.99, will become property of A Second Look and may be sold at a discount, donated, or otherwise disposed of at A Second Look’s discretion.
  • 30 items max per consignor/per week. Items can take up to two weeks to be processed.
  • Items must arrive in a BAG/BOX labeled with your consignor number on the outside. Please DO NOT bring items in plastic totes.
  • Store personnel will determine the selling price of your items, which is typically one-third to one-fourth of the retail value; taking into consideration the quality, condition, demand, and age of the items.
  • Items that are found to be damaged or flawed during the pricing process will be donated. Please note, you will not be notified in the event this occurs. It is imperative you look over your items before dropping off – see backside for “condition of items” to assist you in choosing items to consign.
  • All items may be marked an additional 50% off or more 30 days after being on the sales floor or during special events.

Once an item sells, you will receive 50% of the selling price in your account. You can use the funds as store credit in the store or online or you can request a payout. Payouts can be paid via cash/check in store, sent via Venmo, PayPal, or a check can mailed for a $1 fee.  

**A Second Look is NOT responsible for missing, lost or damaged items for any reason including theft, fire, vandalism, or natural disaster




Condition of Items:


  • Armpits – no holes, no pilling, no deodorant stains, no yellowing, no odor
  • Cuffs – no stains or stretched out
  • Bottom middle area – no holes from rubbing against a belt
  • Neckline/collar – no makeup stains or yellowing
  • Must have a Label – label must not be yellowed or dirty
  • Must not appear shrunken


  • Closure – must have working zipper/button/clasp
  • Inner Thigh – must not be worn out, pilled or thinning
  • Cuffs – must not be ripped or excessively tattered


  • Toes – if visible toes (sandal, peep toe, etc.) must not be able to see toe prints
  • Inside – must not be discolored and heels must not be worn out or pilled
  • Outside – great, clean condition, no bite marks on heels or heels worn down


  • Outside – no peeling or cracking of material
  • Inside – no pilling of fabric, no stains
  • Working zippers
  • Not excessively worn

Intimate Apparel/Sleepwear/Swimwear

  • Must be NWT (new with tag)

Brands That ARE NOT Accepted

  • Faded Glory/No Boundaries
  • George/White Stag
  • Route 66/Jaclyn Smith/Basic Editions
  • LEI
  • Bobbie Brooks
  • Lee
  • Bailey’s Point/North Crest
  • Gloria Vanderbilt
  • Union Bay
  • Alfred Dunner
  • Notations
  • Time & Tru
  • Terra & Sky
  • Sag Harbor




Printed Name___________________________________________      Date____________________


City, State, Zip__________________________________________       Phone___________________



Signature______________________________________________      Consignor # ______________

  1. I would like my items over $49.99 donated to a non-profit after the consignment period ________
  2. I would like to pick up my items that are priced $49.99 and up___________

Sept 2023